Restaurant: Impossible · S5 E11
Caseyville Cafe
Caseyville, Illinois
It has since closed in 2014.
The short answer
Permanently closed around Feb 2014; owned by Diane Emery and daughter Robin Gordon.
What happened on the show
Caseyville Cafe in Caseyville, Illinois, run by Diane Emery and her daughter Robin Gordon, got a fifth season slot on the show's usual terms, a two day rebuild funded on a small renovation budget. Wikipedia carries no summary for the episode, so the on camera details stay off this writeup. The cafe closed permanently around February 2014, confirmed independently by a Yellow Pages listing marked closed and a MapQuest closed tag, both sources standing apart from any rescue show gossip site. For a mother and daughter operation, the ending came within months of the broadcast, joining the cluster of fifth season restaurants whose televised fresh start could not translate into staying power once the crew and cameras had moved on to the next town.
After the cameras left
Caseyville Cafe closed permanently around February 2014. A Yellow Pages listing explicitly marks it closed permanently, and a second business listing carries a closed tag as well, both independent of the reality-show trackers we avoid. Those two directory sources put the closure at high confidence. The family operation run by Diane Emery and daughter Robin Gordon could not turn its television rescue into a lasting business, and the Caseyville location went dark within about a year of the episode.
Location
400-498 Illinois 157, Caseyville IL
More from Robert Irvine
These are Amazon search links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Related reading about Restaurant: Impossible
More on Restaurant: Impossible
Sources
Confidence: high. Last checked 2026-07-19.